by Kurt Achin
Dharamsala, India
Sri Lanka has released an official report, and television documentary, attempting to refute allegations its army committed crimes against humanity as its civil war concluded in 2009. Human rights advocates call the campaign a “whitewash”, but say there are signs Colombo is responding to international pressure.
Defense Secretary Gotabhaya Rajapaksa released his ministry’s official report on Monday on what the army calls its humanitarian mission of 2009. In his comments, Rajapaksa squared off against the “vicious falsehoods” of foreign media.
Probe recommended
Earlier this year, a panel of United Nations-appointed researchers recommended an international probe into the final months of Sri Lanka’s decades-long civil war. Their report concluded there was credible evidence the military may have killed tens of thousands of civilians in deliberate attacks on non-combatant targets such as hospitals. It also acknowledged “Tamil Tiger” separatists probably employed terror tactics, like using hostages as human shields.
Sri Lanka says the U.N. report is biased and false. Alan Keenan, senior analyst for the International Crisis Group, says this latest attempt by Colombo to refute it is deliberately inaccurate.
“They boldly claim in the MoD document that from the very beginning of this humanitarian operation, there was no use of heavy artillery or aerial bombardment. Now, that’s simply a lie. In fact, it’s disproven by their own public statements… We could get you literally tens of thousands of people who would testify,” Keenan said.
Rights group criticism
Human rights groups criticize the Sri Lankan report for glossing over the allegations of civilian massacres, or of the summary execution of captured “Tamil Tiger” prisoners in violation of international laws of war.
The report does concede it may have been impossible to avoid civilian deaths altogether. Meenakshi Ganguly, South Asia Director for Human Rights Watch, says that is significant.
“Clearly this is because they are increasingly faced with credible allegations of war crimes and they are unable to continue the flat denials they’ve engaged in earlier,” Ganguly stated.
New documentary
On another front, Sri Lanka released a professionally produced documentary this week called “Lies Agreed Upon.” It takes aim at another program, “Sri Lanka’s Killing Fields,” produced by Britain’s Channel 4 a few months ago.
“Doctored footage and deliberate lies are presented as authentic,” an announcer says in the documentary. “Numbers are pulled from thin air and presented as fact. Sources are not mentioned, faces hidden, and voices distorted — just like the truth.”
The Sri Lankan documentary includes interviews with doctors who served in hospitals at the heart of the fighting in May 2009. They deny key elements of the influential Channel 4 report, particularly that the hospitals came under attack.
Keenan, from the International Crisis Group, says he believes the doctors gave the interviews under government coercion.
“Sri Lanka is simply not a context in which people can speak freely about their experience of the war… That’s why we need a truly independent investigation, in which they can come forward freely and speak,” he said.
Sri Lanka’s own investigative body — the Lessons Learned and Reconciliation Commission — is expected to issue a report later this year. It provides no witness protection to Sri Lankans who offer testimony, and the U.N. panel report labelled it “inadequate.” courtesy: VOA News
If the “witnesses” who were there during the war and survived are allowed to get out of the country and given protection from the “murderous demons” they will tell a different story!! Every day you hear about murders of civilians in the Tamil areas even now by the security forces. No inquiry, no arrests, the accused or free and continue with their atrocities. Witnesses and immediate family members are threatened with death, so they keep quite and continue their life in misery!!
I wonder how the Rajapakse brothers sleep peacefully and continue to lead a normal life after wreaking so much murder and mayhem in the country!!
Instead of denial and counter offering a video, why cannot the SL government
agree to the call of many democratic nations, including India, for an independent commission of inquiry, consisting of members acceptable to both parties of the conflict?
Sam,
All of Sri Lanka now sleep in peace because the terrorist manace has been wiped out. They are thankful for the leadership provided by Rajapakse brothers in eradicating terror. If you read the annexes to the “Humanitarian Operation – Factual Analysis” you might understand how or why all those who were affected can sleep well in peace now.
“All of Sri Lanka now sleep in peace because the terrorist manace has been wiped out”
I don’t trust trust the “Humanitarian Operation- factual analysis” That is for the Brain washed people like you.
Humanitarian operation in your view is bombing shelling, raping, imprisoning without charges, starving, depriving medicine, lock them behind barbed wire fence, “resettling” under the trees without any assistance, grabbing their lands and giving it to the catchers, not allowing them to go to their own homes and farms!!!
You failed to answer the concerns I raised which is happening in the Tamil areas up to this minute. From your response I gather that you don’t care for the people who does not speak your language!!
I would like to tell you what is happening and happened to the Tamils have happened and will happen to “others” who does not tow the line of the “ruling elite”