Open Letter to the Government on the Recent Arrests and Detentions
December 4th, 2007
4th December 2007
Honorable Mahinda Rajapakse,
President of Sri Lanka
Presidential Secretariat
Colombo 01.
Gotabaya Rajapakse
Secretary
Ministry of Defence, Public Security, Law and Order
Colombo 01.
Honorable Mahinda Samarasinghe
Minister for Disaster Management and Human Rights
Colombo 07.
Chairman Ananda Coomaraswamy
National Human Rights Commission
Colombo 08.
Victor Perera
Inspector General of Police
Police Head Quarters
Colombo 01.
Open Letter to the Government on the Recent Arrests and Detentions
As civil society organizations committed to uphold the equality and dignity of all Sri Lankans, we are deeply concerned about the mass arrests and detentions of Tamils in the first three days of December 2007. The most recent figures available to us for this three day period show that over two thousand people have been arrested and detained.
The levels of harassment and intimidation as well as of arbitrary arrest and detention, abduction and disappearance and extra-judicial execution faced by the Tamil community in Sri Lanka at the hands of the State, the LTTE and other armed groups have greatly increased over the past year. The recent arrests and detentions that have taken place in the course of cordon and search operations carried out islandwide come in the wake of this general pattern. These actions also increase the marginalization and discrimination that the Tamil community has experienced at the hands of successive governments.
In the first three days of December 2007, we have been informed of arrests in and around Colombo, Kalutara, Galle, Puttalam, Pusselawa. The majority of persons detained are young Tamils, mostly males. At least one case of Muslims being arrested has been reported. There are several cases of women who have also been arrested and detained.
We have received reports that the arrests and detentions have not followed existing procedures, thereby violating the basic fundamental rights of the citizens of this country.
Our independent investigations show that many of the people detained were in possession of proper documentation, including police reports, but were arrested nonetheless. The reason or legal basis for arrests has not been provided to those who have been subjected to arrest or their next of kin. The arbitrary nature of the arrests have been made clear in cases where almost entire families have been taken into custody. In a number of cases no information regarding the reason for detention has been provided to those who have been detained or to their relatives. In many cases, the next of kin has not been provided a receipt. These are clear contraventions of the Presidential Guidelines re-issued in July 2007. From independent inquiries it appears that the National Human Rights Commission which is mandated to monitor arrests and detentions, has not received any lists of detainees.
While we acknowledge the need for measures to be taken to combat terrorism and uphold security, these should be in accordance with basic human rights standards and civil liberties. The fundamental reasoning behind security measures is to protect the rights of civilians, not to curtail or violate them.
We urge the authorities to ensure that existing laws are respected while carrying out security checks. Arbitrary arrests and detentions contravene the basic essence of the rights incorporated in the fundamental rights chapter in the Constitution of Sri Lanka, ensuring that all citizens are equal before the law and should be protected from arbitrary arrests, detention, cruel and inhuman treatment and torture.
We are also concerned about the conditions faced by the detainees. Large numbers of people were taken into Police Stations which had limited space to accommodate them, and which lacked basic facilities such as toilets and drinking water. In October 2007, during his visit to Sri Lanka, the UN Special Rapporteur on Torture, Manfred Nowak, referred to poor conditions in detention centers which were often over crowded, resulting in inhuman treatment. He also makes specific reference to the use of torture by the TID in the detention centre at Boosa.
Further, the lack of information about the location of detention centers and the restrictions placed on the access to detainees have resulted in limited or no contact between the detainees and their families or legal counsel. This has further marginalized the detainees, curtailing their legal rights. Recent restrictions of movement from the North due to security reasons have also added to the burden where families have been separated, with many young people possibly having no contact with their families.
On the 8th of June 2007, the Supreme Court of Sri Lanka deplored the eviction of 376 Tamils from Colombo and provided interim relief ensuring that further evictions would not take place. This measure demonstrated that all citizens are equal before the law and have the inalienable right to reside in any place that he/she chooses, freedom of movement, and protection from cruel inhuman treatment and torture. Such standards must be adhered to and respected, ensuring that all citizens are treated equally.
We the undersigned urge the authorities to take the following measures:
+ Release all persons who are held without due cause
+ Prevent further arbitrary arrests and detentions taking place
+ Ensure that persons already detained are provided access to family and legal counsel
+ Allow immediate access to all detention centres by ICRC to meet will all prisoners detained
+ Follow the existing rules and procedures laid out in the emergency regulations and Presidential Directives regarding due process in arrests and detentions including informing relatives and HRC of the arrest, and the provision of a receipt
+ The Help Desk to be set up by the Ministry of Human Rights should include a publicly available central registry of detainees and detention centres.
+ Lists of detainees, updated daily, should be posted in places of detention in Tamil as well as Sinhala
+ The Human Rights Commission should, in accordance with its mandate:
+ immediately activate its emergency hotline
+ actively monitor arrests and detention, including making immediate visits to areas where mass arrests are reported to take place and about to take place.
- urgently visit places where detainees are alleged to be held and make available to the public details of such visits along with their observations and recommendations;
- monitor and make inquires into the procedures followed in arresting and detaining persons,
* In addition, the Human Rights Commission should maintain a public list of detainees and places of detention in all regional centres and on its webpage, which should be updated daily
* Cease immediately the practice of torture in detention camps and police custody by prosecution of those responsible
* Improve the conditions of detention centers
* Take on board and implement the recommendations made by the Special Rapporteur on Torture following his visit to Sri Lanka in October 2007
Signatories:
Association of War Affected Women
Centre for Human Rights and Democracy
Centre for Policy Alternatives
Equal Ground
Free Media Movement
Home for Human Rights
INFORM Human Rights Documentation Centre
International Friends for Global Peace
International Movement Against Discrimination and Racism
Law and Society Trust
Mothers and Daughters of Lanka
Muslim Information Centre
National Peace Council
Women and Media Collective
Entry Filed under: transCurrents
6 Comments Add your own
1. Roger Francis | December 4th, 2007 at 11:19 pm
Dear Sirs: I will like to highlight a section from an American website about arbitrary arrests. I really worry when “holier than thou” western nations preach about how to react to terrorist attacks that have plagued our nation for over 25 years now. I also want to know why CPA and FMM were strangely silent when the terrorists attacks happened last Wednesday. I agree arrests of this large scale serve no purpose, but can CPA and FMM guarantee that we in Colombo and suburbs are free of Tamil Terrorists? What about measures USA and Britain take when they are faced with terrorist attacks? Will the CPA be liable for damages to life and property if some of t the people released turn out to be terrorists? I did not hear them condemn the terrorist attacks or the suicide cadre attack on a democratically elected TAMIL person in the Cabinet. I am confused.
EXCERPT
WASHINGTON - Measures take by the U.S. administration against Arab and Muslim immigrants after the Sep. 11, 2001 terrorist attacks against New York and the Pentagon have not only failed to protect U.S. security, but may have made it more vulnerable, according to a major report released here Thursday.
The round-up and detention of more than 1,200 immigrants after the attacks were particularly abusive, says the report by the Washington-based Migration Policy Institute (MPI) an influential think tank.
It said that the government’s efforts to depict some of those who were detained as terrorists were simply wrong. ‘The only charges brought against them were actually for routine immigration violations or ordinary crimes,'’ concludes the 165-page report, ‘’America’s Challenge: Domestic Security, Civil Liberties and National Unity After September 11′’.
‘’Many of the policies that have been adopted in the wake of Sep. 11 are an attempt to use immigration as a proxy for anti-terrorism,'’ said Vincent Cannistraro, a former senior counter-terrorism official in the Central Intelligence Agency (CIA), who is on MPI’s board of advisers and helped prepare the report.
‘’We haven’t learned anything about pre-empting terrorism in America, but we have intimidated, antagonized and alienated many (minority) communities (which is) counter-productive to what the FBI and other agencies are trying to do,’ he added at the report’s release.
What breakthroughs have been made in identifying and apprehending terrorists have been the result of traditional police and intelligence work and co-operation and information-sharing with foreign intelligence agencies, not from any of the immigration initiatives taken by the administration, says the report, which also includes the most comprehensive compilation of the individuals detained after 9/11 and their experiences. -END EXCERPT
I humbly hope this will awaken the Western Ambassadors who preach to Sri Lanka about their own behaviour.
2. ilaya seran senguttuven | December 5th, 2007 at 12:05 am
This humane effort of men and women from all communities, committed to prevent the bigotry and injustice that has eaten into the ruling clique, is one more example there is much space for Sri Lankans to build a united, accomodative and plural society in the future rising above parochial race/religious considerations. I am appalled in this enlightened 21st century there remain among us men and women insensitively trying to re-enact the scenes from
that part of Nazi-dominated Europe during WW2 - events that stand condemned by all humanity today. That this should happen in this land said to be sanctified by the teachings of The Enlightened one AGAIN in a period of a few months baffles the mind.
3. Gamunu | December 5th, 2007 at 4:55 am
I am disgusted with my government for doing this cruelty to Tamil people.
4. mahendra | December 5th, 2007 at 1:25 pm
In a situation like this, where terrorists are all over it is the responsibility of any Governing body to protect its people. If a bomb explosion occurs and innocent civilians get killed & injured all those so civil organisations blame the authorities for not protecting them which happened all these years & still LTTE terrorists continues their brutal attacks everywhere. Therefore these organisations should give every possible assistance to eradicate this menance from this country create a peaceful enviourenment all peace loving people of this country. At the same time it should be the responsibility of the Govt. to protect the civic rights of the people with minimal hazzle to them.
5. romesh | December 5th, 2007 at 3:04 pm
Dont forget these are the kind of acts that help to create terrorism in Srilanka in the first place. When are you going to learn your lessons?, As long as such short sighted and narrow minded people are in power , Srilanka have a long way to go before we see peace returns to this beatiful island
6. jay | December 11th, 2007 at 2:23 pm
Its very strange to witness the world wide out cry against the mass arrest & lock ups.
Why am i not witnessing any sort of out cry for sucide bombings, day light massacres & butchery
Why am i seeing celebrations on heros day and black tiger days. Why am i hearing british MP’s addressing fallen heros (many of whom are suicide bombers) celebrations
I know why. Road side bombs, suicide killings and day light masscre are a part of freedom struggle.
Leave a Comment
Subscribe to the comments via RSS Feed