transCurrents Home

Impunity, a debilitating fixture in state culture

25 years after Welikada massacre

by Rajan Hoole

Colombo’s Welikada high security prison was the scene of two massacres of Tamil political prisoners during the communal violence of July 1983, first after lunch on July 25 claiming 35 prisoners and second, about 4.00 PM on the July 27 claiming a further 18. On both occasions Secretary of Justice Mervyn Wijesinghe asked Colombo Magistrate Keerthi Srilal Wijewardene to hold inquests with the assistance of Tilak Marapone and C.R. de Silva (the present AG) from the Attorney General’s Department. No culprits were identified and the case was hushed up.

[Welikda Prison-www.prisons.gov.lk]

The massacres made life a living hell also for those on the spot, who driven by moral aversion tried unsuccessfully stop them, but were not even allowed to clear their names.

The inquest

One of them, Superintendent of Prisons (SP) Alexis Leo de Silva, upon hearing the alarm on the 25th, rushed into the mob in the Chapel Section with ASPs Amarasinghe and Munaweera, followed by Deputy Commissioner (DC) Cutty Jansz, but to little avail. Leo felt very angry that the army unit at the prison headed by Lt. Mahinda Hathurusinghe, 4th Artillery, did nothing to stop the murder, and later also blocked emergency hospitalization of injured survivors. A lieutenant would hardly have dared to override DC Jansz and doomed the survivors, without prompting from Army HQ. While some prison staff protected Tamils, others, including a jailor, attacked the survivors in the compound.

At the inquest on the 26th, Leo wanted to place the truth on record. Magistrate Wijewardene left out chunks of his testimony. Leo’s son Lalanath de Silva recently told us, “An AG’s department counsel called my father outside the room where the inquest was being held and attempted to persuade my father to go along - pleading that the truth would place Sri Lanka in a very adverse position internationally.” At one point the Magistrate became so angry that he refused to take down Leo’s testimony.

The Police under Detective Superintendent Hyde Silva questioned the survivors on the 26th following the Magistrate’s order. To Suriya Wickremasinghe of the Civil Rights Movement belongs the credit for painstakingly seeking out survivors of the massacres, interviewing them and keeping the issue alive. She told us that survivor Manikkadasan in his statement to the Police, blamed two jailors of active complicity. A thin jailor warned him that mention of names might lead to similar jeopardy from inmates.

Eyewitnesses

Suriya believes that the second massacre owed to earlier survivors being also eyewitnesses. On the 27th Lt. Nuvolari Seneviratne of Army Engineers commanded the platoon outside the prison. Hearing a commotion where the survivors had been re-housed, Nuvolari radioed the Duty Officer (DO) at Army HQ. He told the Junior DO who answered that he wanted authority to go into prison and disperse the mob. The Junior DO gave him a telephone number and asked him to phone the DO (a colonel). Nuvolari used the coin phone at the entrance to ring the number at Army HQ. The DO told him to stick to standing orders and stay outside prison, or would face court-martial if he went in. Nuvolari asked for the Army Commander. He was refused, being told the Commander was with President Jayewardene, and relief was being sent to deal with the problem. (Cutty Jansz had also phoned Army HQ.)

The relief, commandos under Major Sunil Peiris, promptly went in and saved 19 of the 37 prisoners. Nuvolari felt the deaths to be sheer murder, which his platoon could have prevented if not constrained by HQ. At the second inquest, the AG’s men, Marapone and de Silva, were keenly selective. Leo who was in prison the whole day, had at the first forebodings asked DC Jansz to expedite the removal of the survivors to safety. As if by design, the attack began when he went for a late snack in lieu of lunch, causing him to rush back. Neither he nor his ASPs were called upon to testify at the inquest.

The AG’s men and Magistrate tried to frame a jailbreak attempt that supposedly left inadequate resources to prevent the massacre. The AG’s men and Army’s lawyers importuned Lt. Seneviratne to tell the inquest that he was outside the prison controlling a jailbreak. He refused. The world had crashed around the 22-year-old sportsman from Trinity College who joined the Army with high hopes. Major Sunil Peiris stepped in saying not to harass Nuvolari and if he won’t, he won’t, and if their object was having someone from the Army testify, he would.

To a leading question, Major Peiris answered with professional precision, “I did not notice any prisoners attempting to break out. Therefore I gathered that the attempted mass jail break had been contained before our arrival!” Undeterred by Peiris’ refusal to perjure, the Magistrate summed up, “...prompt and efficient steps taken by the special unit of the Army under witness Major Peiris had effectively prevented the jail break ... and helped quell the mob which might otherwise have caused [even greater death].”

Taming scandals and condemning posterity

In July 2001, President Kumaratunge appointed the Presidential ‘Truth’ Commission on Ethnic Violence headed by former Chief Justice Suppiah Sharvananda, with S.S. Sahabandu and M.M. Zuhair. Suriya Wickremasinghe had repeatedly been thwarted in her efforts to obtain from the Police, testimony they received from the survivors of the first massacre. The Commission, which relied heavily on Suriya’s work, could have followed this up to further its investigations, but did not.

Tamil survivors named to us Jailor Rogers Jayasekere, Jailor Samitha Rathgama and Location Officer Palitha as the protagonists on the ground. Senior prison officials have indirectly affirmed Jayasekere’s culpability. His family were strong UNP supporter from President Jayewardene’s old Kelaniya electorate, shared in 1983 by Ranil Wickremasinghe and Cyril Mathew. Rumours charged that gangsters under Gonawala Sunil of Kelaniya UNP fame were brought into prison to assist the second massacre.

Vehicle check

Nuvolari Seneviratne’s testimony bears relevance here. His soldiers at the entrance checked the vehicles going into the prison to ensure they were the government’s. Jail guards just inside the entrance did the identity checks. The soldiers at the entrance told Nuvolari that some of the official vehicles entering took underworld figures, but exited without them. Asked who the underworld figures were, Seneviratne replied, “I did not see them myself and there is no way my men would have known them. But the jail guards knew them as persons in and out of jail. They told my men.”

During the second massacre, Journalist Aruna Kulatunga wrote recently, he saw airline hijacker Sepala Ekanayake coming out of the prison gates screaming “kohomada ape wede” (How is our job?), felled by a thundering blow from Major Sunil Peiris. Peiris had told me something more, that Sepala was carrying a severed human head.

Senior prison staff dismissed this as fantasy. I published it in my book Arrogance of Power, since I knew Peiris. I had checked back with Peiris, who, a little hurt, explained, ‘You know your Bible? It was like John the Baptist’s head on a charger’. It happened before Peiris saw the scene of crime. Peiris’ action makes sense only if Sepala’s utterance, reported also by Kulatunga, drew his attention to something revolting. Peiris’ testimony at the inquest speaks for truthfulness and accuracy that are hallmarks of a good officer. Nuvolari’s refusal to perjure again stands his testimony in good stead.

About when Peiris’ party arrived, Nuvolari’s men drew his attention to a fresh hole in the prison wall near the cricket ground. Upon inspection he saw an Air Force truck standing by. No words were exchanged. The Army’s legal unit also removed Nuvolari’s standing orders and the logbook with records of vehicles entering. On 27th, the Tamil detainees fought back, some attackers were mauled and soldiers shot some, but there is no account of casualties. SP Leo de Silva felt impelled by his honour to place the truth on record. His later investigations were stalled by an order from Commissioner Delgoda. Then Justice Minister Nissanka Wijeratne threw Leo out of service at the age of 56 by refusing a routine extension. The total cover up and a diversity of coherent testimony pointing to the nefarious deployment of broader resources, gives surely the lie to representing the massacres as an outburst of subaltern patriotism. No perpetrators were named and Sepala walks free. Is it not because they have beans to spill?

Whether or not directly intended, what our commissions and AG’s Dept. achieve is to protect the State’s inbuilt abuses that have gone over tolerable limits. The blame for its repeated crimes is invariably shuffled off to subaltern sectors. The routine official prevarication also leads to Sinhalese seeing the ethnic problem as Tamils making mountains of molehills, and the solution as being to knock them about, pat them on the head and give them sweets to suck.

[Dr. Rajasunderam, Mr. Kuttimani and Mr. Thangathurai were among the 52 Tamil political prisoners]

Regrettably, few Sinhalese would be shocked that Attorney General C.R. de Silva guides important commission proceedings such as the ACF investigation. He, or Marapone, tried to stop Leo de Silva 25 years ago, pleading that ‘the truth would place Sri Lanka in an adverse position internationally’. Lanka would have redeemed itself had all such crimes been faced squarely long ago, rather than make fixers of truth a permanent feature of the State. On a further point, the prison murders of rising Tamil leaders Dr. Rajasundaram, Kuttimani and Thangathurai led to the fracture of the original Tamil youth leadership and the rise of Prabhakaran. That is another intricate story.

Comments

Beautiful work, Dr. Hoole.

The Sri Lankan state and the liberal-left pretenders who defend it in knee-jerk fashion, stand exposed as unspeakably evil and depraved. It is too late for any redemption. - Expatriate

Posted by: Expatriate | July 19, 2008 08:54 PM

The writer correctly stated what happened at the Welikade. More can be said about it. But the real culprit were Cyril Mathew and JRJ. As the President of all the people of Sri Lanka he should not have appeared in military uniform and stated “if they want a war, let there be a war”. When the mindset of JRJ was exposed in such a manner, the people cannot expect justice from the State machinery. Later it is the same JRJ who shouted "sun stroke, sun stroke" through fear when Rajiv Gandhi was assaulted by the Naval rating.

Gonawala Sunil of Kelaniya was a notorious criminal at that time doing all the nefarious activities under the shadow of Cyril Mathew. At the same time there was a competition between the TELO and the LTTE for supremacy. TELO was the darling of Indra Gandhi while the LTTE was attached to MGR and had its people in high positions under people like Cyril Mathew. When Kuttumani and his friends were in Welikade jail, the TELO planned a commando rescue operation after the successful operation at the Chavakachcheri Police Station and at Murukandy where they killed almost 190 government forces who were on their way to Colombo after looting the jewels from the Tamils. The TELO wanted the LTTE to delay their operation until the prisoners are rescued from Welikade jail. The hurriedness of the LTTE helped the Sinhalese goons under Cyril Mathew to slaughter the Tamil detainees in a shameless manner. It was planned by the Sinhalese politicians like Cyril Mathew to help the LTTE to massacre those political detainees.

Sepala Ekanayake was charged for hijaking a plane and is considered to be a grave crime. Just imagine the mind-set of some politicians and some Sinhalese who were praising him as a hero when he gambled with the lives of hundreds of passengers in the mid-sky. Such a mind-set of the Sinhalese political leaders continued when the naval rating was released immediately soon after R.Premadasa assumed power. No doubt there is a large section of the Sinhalese (including SP Leo de Silva, Major Sunil Peiris) who are ashamed of this savage act. Today the armed forces too are brain-washed by the politicians.

Finally mention should be made that the writer was correct when he wrote that the prison murders of rising Tamil leaders Dr. Rajasundaram, Kuttimani and Thangathurai led to the fracture of the original Tamil youth leadership and the rise of Prabhakaran. Otherwise the question would be - had Dr.Rajasundaram and Kuttimani been alive today what would have happened to VP. The question before the Sinhalese people is why should they elect people like Cyril Mathew, R.Premadasa and now Mervyn and some more under whom all notorious criminals move among the public and evade law. Today it is evident Pottu Nauffer who shot and killed High Court Judge Sarath Ambepitiya (engaged in drug trafficking and illegal activities with the indirect blessings of a Minister) is also enjoying the comforts while in prison. The curse among the Sinhalese is that political leaders like Cyril Mathew, R.Premadasa and now Mervyn and some more under whom all notorious criminals flourish and disrespect law. The curse among the Tamils is that the Tamil Movements are not united among themselves. Even the Muslims have links with international Islamic terrorist organizations with the indirect blessings of some politicians. All these have promoted gun culture. This is the plight of Sri Lanka. - A.Rajasingam

Posted by: A.Rajasingam | July 19, 2008 11:34 PM

Groan! When are we going to stop talking about 1983?

Sri Lanka, not just the Tamils, has suffered worse in the last 25 years. Impunity is a fact of life and nobody significant is accountable for anything. Under these circumstances, what do we gain by wallowing in such insignificant details as to who killed Kuttimani?

Kuttimani, as Dr Hoole will confirm, was a smuggler and not considered to be in the same league as the "Tamil youth leadership", whose loss he laments.

Sepala is currently making a measly living driving tourists, in his beat up old Jeep, to Horton Plains and other attractions in the Nuwara Eliya area.

Kuttimani and Sepala were not even 'bit players' in the ethnic problem. Even Prabhakaran and the LTTE, are only an outcome of the problem, and not the problem (National perception that Sri Lankan = Sinhalese) itself. The fact that Prabhakaran survived when the other Tamil militants didn't is not because he was violent and the others were not. The EPRLF, TELO, PLOTE and a host of other groups were just as prone to terrorising unarmed civillians (Appu's definition of a terrorist) as the LTTE or the Sri Lankan Armed forces.

Nothing short of forward thinking can help us leave all this misery in the past. Dredging up the past, no matter how meticulously, isn't going to get us anywhere or prevent us from repeating the mistakes of the past.

Unlike South Africa, where the Anglican Church under Tutu played an iconic role in the freedom struggle, a Truth and Reconcilliation Commission is a non-starter in Sri Lanka... a country where the word IMPUNITY is defined as a "commission of inquiry.'

The 1983 riots have been rehashed in great detail and analysed and reported on for the last 25 years. And yet, look at where we are today? We are a nation that "asks and eats parippu."

All we do is ask for more... http://parippuplease.blogspot.com/

- Gini Appu

Posted by: Gini Appu | July 20, 2008 06:15 AM

Murder of persons in state custody is a greater crime than even deliberate murder of civilians not in custody.
Courts hand out custodial sentences trusting the state to safeguard and reform criminal offenders.

There is a long record of deaths in custody - in prisons, police stations, in courthouses and during transport of prisoners. The welikade massacre was a planned exercise by fellow inmates which could have been prevented.
This embittered the minds of tamils more than anything else. Most who could afford, fled the country realising that they had no protection even in custody. - nathan

Posted by: nathan | July 21, 2008 10:27 AM

Gini Appu

You call Kuttimani a smuggler because you were hidden his freedom fight aspect to liberate the Tamils from oppression. Sinhales are shown the dirty side of Tamils.

If we look at similar personal level, SWRD Bandaranayake was a homosexist and so was Dahanayake, both prime ministers. Srimavo was running around with men. JR was believed to keep his son's wife and was a killer.

Who is better, Thangathurai or the rotten leaders of Sri Lanka?

Posted by: Sarwan | July 21, 2008 10:39 AM

Dr. Hoole

Thanks for your well researched reports on Sri Lanka. Every successive report,including your recent ones on the Mutur and Trinco killings, and the dire situation of hapless Tamils in the Vanni and the East offer cmpelling evidence that the Rajapakse regime is now engaged in genocide against Tamils.

In fact that should not be a suprise, considering that Rajapakse beieves in the Sinhala chauvinist ideology that Sri Lanka is a divinely inspired Sinhala Buddhist state.

I would urge you to examine whether the charge of genocide against Rajapakse can be substantiated.That would indeed be a tremendous contribution . - saravanan

Posted by: saravanan | July 23, 2008 09:59 PM

Post a comment

(The comment may need to be approved by transcurrents.com. Until then, it won't appear on the entry. Thanks for waiting.)

Recent Posts

on TC