"If we keep helping we become the jailer of these people”
"If we keep helping we become the jailer of these people,” a western diplomat is quoted as saying in a New York Times Article by Lydia Polgreen, dated from Cheddikulam, Vavuniya.
The diplomat was commenting on displaced Tamils remaining hidden from view and continued "funding being provided by several foreign countries to feed, shelter and clothe the displaced."
Full text of Many Sri Lanka War Refugees Languish in Camps, by Lydia Polgreen:
When the piercing whistle and sharp thuds of artillery shells grew faint, S. Theventhran dashed to safety. After days of cowering in a narrow, open trench on a strip of beach in the northeastern corner of Sri Lanka, he was cheered by the sight of Sri Lankan Army soldiers helping wounded and terrified survivors of the last stand of the Tamil Tiger rebels, who had held nearly 300,000 Tamil civilians hostage.
More than two months later, Mr. Theventhran, a 56-year-old Tamil civil servant, finds himself once again a captive, this time of the people who freed him from the Tigers’ grip.
“We were liberated,” he said in an interview at one of the sprawling, closed camps set up here to house those displaced in the war against the rebel group, known as the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam. “Now we are prisoners again. I lost everything in this war. The Tigers killed my son. I lost my property. Now I have lost my freedom, too.”
Hundreds of thousands of Tamils remain locked behind razor wire in camps almost entirely off limits to journalists, human rights investigators and political leaders. The Sri Lankan government claims that the people in the camps are a security risk because Tamil Tiger fighters are hiding among them.
But diplomats, analysts, aid workers and many Sri Lankans worry that the historic chance to finally bring to a close one of the world’s most enduring and vicious ethnic conflicts is slipping away as the government curtails the rights of Tamil civilians in its efforts to stamp out the last remnants of the Tigers.
“The government told these people it would look after them,” said Veerasingham Anandasangaree, a prominent Tamil politician who has been a staunch supporter of the government’s fight against the Tamil Tigers. “But instead they have locked them up like animals with no date certain of when they will be released. This is simply asking for another conflict later on down the road.”
The Sri Lankan government has portrayed its final battle against the 26-year insurgency by the Tamil Tigers, which ended in late May with the killing of the group’s leader, Vellupillai Prabhakaran, as a rescue mission to liberate civilians held hostage by one of the world’s richest and most ruthless armed groups, branded terrorists by governments across the globe.
“We can’t say this was a war, it was a humanitarian operation to safeguard the people of the area,” said Sri Lanka’s president, Mahinda Rajapaksa, in a rare interview this week. “They knew we were not against the Tamil people, against the civilians. This was only against the terrorists.”
Although many of the camps’ residents are grateful to the government for freeing them from the Tigers, frustration and anger are building as it becomes clear that reconciliation and finding a political solution to the grievances of the Tamil and other minority groups in Sri Lanka will have to wait.
Conditions in the camps have improved since the early days in April and May when the sudden influx of hundreds of thousands of people caught the government and aid groups flatfooted. Hundreds of sturdy shelters are being built to replace hot, flimsy tents.
Children are attending schools, and health centers and hospitals are helping check the spread of infectious diseases. New water pumps and toilets have made life a little more bearable for the displaced.
But that has done little to tamp down the impatience of those living here. The screening process has lasted far longer than most people had imagined. Mr. Rajapaksa said he had ordered that 80 percent of the displaced should be resettled by the end of the year. But government officials say that this goal may be tough to meet because the extensive land mines across much of the north have not been cleared.
Many of the displaced people here said they would happily leave the crowded camps to stay with relatives elsewhere in the country until they could return to their villages. Some elderly people have been allowed to leave, but government officials refused to say when others who have been screened would be released.
Mr. Rajapaksa said that the residents of the camps, which the government refers to as “welfare villages,” must be confined for security reasons because anyone could be a hidden rebel fighter. The government says about 10,000 fighters have been identified so far, most because they turned themselves in.
Indeed, the murky status of the people held here in what many describe as internment camps is emblematic of the conundrum at the heart of Sri Lanka’s civil war. The Tamil Tigers so thoroughly insinuated themselves into Tamil communities, particularly here in the Tamil Tiger’s former stronghold in he north, that in the government’s eyes the two have become virtually synonymous.
“They recruited everybody,” Mr. Rajapaksa said, from old men to teenage girls. “Everyone was ready to take the gun.”
Mr. Rajapaksa, who was elected in 2005 after promising to end the war, has cast the struggle against the Tamil Tigers as part of the war against terrorism. He is fond of saying that there are no minorities in Sri Lanka, “only people who love their country and people who don’t love their country.”
Sri Lanka’s government has celebrated its triumph over the Tigers as the world’s first purely military defeat of an insurgent terrorist group. Using ingenious guerrilla tactics, women and children as suicide bombers and even a small navy and air force, the Tigers waged a pitiless battle to sever a homeland for the minority Tamil ethnic group from the rest of Sri Lanka, a teardrop-shaped island. The war spanned nearly three decades and left tens of thousands of people dead and uprooted hundreds of thousands more.
But human rights organizations here and abroad have documented some of the other heavy costs of the victory. The government has clamped down hard on dissent. Journalists have been mysteriously killed, arrested and chased from the country. Thousands of Tamils have disappeared, presumably arrested by the state on suspicion of being Tamil Tiger fighters, according to Mano Ganesan, a Tamil member of Parliament who has been tracking disappearances for years.
Questions remain about how many civilians were killed in the last bloody weeks of the war, when the Tigers were pushed onto a narrow stretch of beach along with hundreds of thousands of civilians. After insisting for months, improbably, that no civilians had died, Mr. Rajapaksa acknowledged that some must have been killed and said that the government was investigating the last days of the war.
“My instruction was there cannot be any single civilian causalities,” he said. “The army was very careful.”
But the United Nations has said that at least 7,000 people died up to the end of April, when the last push began. No one is sure how many were killed in the last few weeks of fighting, but witnesses said the battlefield was covered with bodies. Satellite images of the zone seem to belie government claims that no heavy weapons were used there, revealing large, scorched craters.
“We had to walk over dead bodies,” said Priyadharshai Jeeveraj, whose husband, a salaried policeman who had worked for the Tigers, was arrested on the last day of the fighting and has not been seen since. “There were hundreds of bodies everywhere.”
The Sri Lankan government has managed to brush off outside efforts to investigate what happened in the final days of the fighting, quashing an effort to so by the Human Rights Council in Geneva in May.
But the longer the camps for displaced Tamils remain hidden from view, the harder it will be for the Sri Lankan government to keep the support of the foreign countries helping to pay the millions of dollars required to feed, shelter and clothe the displaced.
“Perversely, if we keep helping we become the jailer of these people,” said one diplomat from a country that is helping pay for the relief effort. Aid organizations that had initially been barred from working in the camps have stayed silent to maintain their ability to help the displaced. But many have reservations about their role.
“The longer it goes on, the more it looks like internment,” said one aid official, who asked not to be identified to protect the charity’s work.
But Mr. Rajapaksa said that preventing the Tamil Tigers from regrouping was his first priority.
“The citizen’s security is No. 1,” he said. “You must remember that we have just defeated the most ruthless terrorist group. We are very careful. I can’t let this become like Baghdad.”

6 Comments
This article raises some pertinent issues. First off, landmines. Where is the proof that these are indeed such a big threat, as the Government claims. The Sri Lankan Army is busy looting Tamil homes in the Wanni - clearly mines are not an impediment to their mobility. Buddhist monks were able to travel freely to Mullaitivu (I have seen a video on YouTube). Mines were not an issue in that instance?
The second issue has to do with indoctrination. Five years or 30 years does not make a difference. The only ones who would need rehabilitation are Black Tigers, and that is a tiny percentage of the total LTTE force. During WWII, the German people were subject to perhaps the most sophisticated, intense propaganda barrage ever. Live parades (with thousands of soldiers), newspapers, the radio, Hitler Youth Schools, and of course Hitler's mesmerizing speeches. Yet the Allies did not try to "rehabilitate" the German populace. They knew that the people had accepted defeat and simply wanted to get on with their lives. Of course there would be those who raised the Nazi flag or continued to sympathize with National Socialism, but this could NOT be stopped. Today there are pro-Nazi and Skinhead groups all over Europe, America, North America, and Australia, but no one really cares, since they are essentially harmless.
If anything, I would say that Southern Sri Lanka is in need of rehabilitation. With its crumbling institutions, full of corrupt and incompetent buffoons, and post-colonial hangover, it could use a lot of help. But I wouldn't go so far as to say people should be locked up in camps. Instead, the (Sinhalese) people need to be presented with the truth, piece by piece. That the LTTE was not nearly as bad as they presumed. That a Tamil Eelam would have done for Sri Lanka what a South India did for India. That an incompetent, corrupt Government is NOT a good thing, and the onus is on the Southern voter to change things. The list is endless.
Mahinda has replaced Piraba, he may say allsorts excusesfor building up a big military machine , keeps the tamils under cntrol but his hidden agenda is he has be come another fascist more like mugabe.
Government seems to have opted for a policy of using forced internment as opposed to winning over the hearts and minds of the Tamil people.
It would have been possible to win over hearts and minds of those who escaped if the correct approach had been in place at the very beginning. Now that opportunity seems to have been lost and replaced by suspicion and need for continuous surveilance of the IDP's. This extra-judicial treatment based on mere suspicion could be interpreted as war crimes against the civilian population and could be held against those responsible in the ICJ.
LTTE is the symptom of the CONSTANT CAUSE The SinHella racism which is the cause and rampant in each and every institution in the sick Srilankan racist state.
If the Srilanka DID not intimidate, dicriminate and massacre Tamils before the LTTE, Tamils never ever created LTTE nor they support LTTE but the SinHella racists Srilanka doing the VERY SAME atrocities to the so called LIBERATED TAMILS in the CINCENTRATION CAMPS to force the Tamils to create another LTTE and the future armed struggle will be not like the defeated LTTE who never ever had policies of mass killings of sinhalese.
Mahinda when he was interviewed by Ram of Hindu newspaper. He was questioned about the resettlement of people who are being held in internments camp, this is what he said." I feel those people who are in the camps have to be send back to their villages and homes for me to do that I need to have another 200,000 soldiers to provide security and I can not do that now." That means he is not in a position to provide security now so until such time they have to stay in the camps. Though he did not say like that you can infer from his statement that he is planning to keep these people for indefinite period. My question is if he is now celebrating the victory of defeating Tigers and all the leaders and fighters of LTTE have be eliminated completely, why does he wants to recruit more solders to give security for whom and from what. Does he think that, the Tamilians from Tamil Nadu will send the army to fight against his forces? That will never happen, then why does he want so many troops to give security to the innocent and poor Tamils who are just innocent victims. Their fault is, they were in a wrong place at the wrong time. They are not interested to fight against Mahinda’s army. All they want now is to live a free and peaceful life in their own homeland with out any interference from anyone. Is this too much to be asked from a Leader of a country? If he can not do this, what is he planning to do? Is he trying to kill everyone in the camp in the next few years and put the blame on the war and Tigers and then send who ever left to mingle with the Singhalese settlers in Wanni? Why is the world closing the eyes and let this to happen. Is the United Nation is for Nations and its People or its only for the Governments? Any madman like Mahinda can creep in to power using the demo_crazy as an excuse and govern its people in an undemocratic manner follow the paths of countries like Russia, China, Iran, North Korea or Cuba. Are we going to let this happen? This is really crazy.
Accrding to the article, one diplomat from a country that is helping pay for the relief effort says
“Perversely, if we keep helping we become the jailer of these people,” ....
Only two months passed and SL government is doing it best to resettle almost all IDP in 180 days ... Demining/Electrification/Roads and other infrastructure are being built very fast .... and not a single terror bomb has exploded after the elimination of war due to strict checking of the presence of LTTEer's in the IDP camps ....
These diplomats are very jealous about the country and always want to put a spoke in the wheel and would be very happy to see any bomb explosion in the country ... They expected and came to SL thinking SL is another third world country with backboneless people ... But, they are realising it is not so ... Now they want to create many obstacles so that SL does not zoom to another level of development ... This time, I do not think they could achieve their aims .. May be under Ranil/Mangala/Kotialle government which is very far far away ... We will see how this same diplomat would behave after the IDP's resettlement ... I'm pretty sure he will never give any credit for that and will go on finding another 'imaginary' fault ... Why not disclose the country of this diplomat so that srilankans see his real face ....